Tell me in so many words how broken the American system is. I mostly agree, just want to emphasize the root problem is the legality of the business practice. The core question remains, sure. The more important questions are imo why is this legal and how can it be changed. The very basics should be that the system doesn’t proliferate practices that inevitably pose such “greater good scenarios”, these should only arise with illegal practices in the first place. Also: the notion of a greater good scenario implies that anything changes - I don’t see anything meaningful changing as of yet. They changed the visibility of leadership on websites ffs . This is so sad.

The core question is simple enough, rule of law needs to be upheld regardless. I just hope the person never gets caught.

That’s what I summarised, aside from the us-centric references. I still don’t quite understand the emphasis on “true individual liberty”, what that should entail and the meaning of it for the discussion. I agree with everything else you said, that part just isn’t clear to me.

What’s your definition of liberty here? Just the absence of constraints? As in to be free from sth., opposed to being free to do sth.?

If it is, then sure you can have individual liberty. It’s just (almost) utterly useless. Or do I not get your point here?